Sermon preached on November 11, 2018
I want you to be free from anxieties. The unmarried man is anxious about the things of the Lord, how to please the Lord. But the married man is anxious about worldly things, how to please his wife, and his interests are divided. And the unmarried or betrothed woman is anxious about the things of the Lord, how to be holy in body and spirit. But the married woman is anxious about worldly things, how to please her husband. I say this for your own benefit, not to lay any restraint upon you, but to promote good order and to secure your undivided devotion to the Lord. If anyone thinks that he is not behaving properly toward his betrothed, if his passions are strong, and it has to be, let him do as he wishes: let them marry—it is no sin. But whoever is firmly established in his heart, being under no necessity but having his desire under control, and has determined this in his heart, to keep her as his betrothed, he will do well. So then he who marries his betrothed does well, and he who refrains from marriage will do even better. A wife is bound to her husband as long as he lives. But if her husband dies, she is free to be married to whom she wishes, only in the Lord. Yet in my judgment she is happier if she remains as she is. And I think that I too have the Spirit of God.
1 Corinthians 7:32-40
Paul has been guiding us through a narrow pass between the ditches. On both sides we are confronted with extreme errors. As with the excesses and defects that flank Aristotle’s golden mean in this or that virtue, so here, there is usually one side or the other to which each man is prone. Likewise, there is one or the other that more characteristically opposes the mean, as cowardice more nearly opposes courage, whereas the foolhardy go wrong by a counterfeit.1
In the case of marriage and singleness, the gold that the Apostle would dust off of marriage would seem to guide us forward through the excess of domestic tranquility—at its extreme being more like a suburban tranquilizer of the spirit—and the defect of unattachment—its own extreme being infidelity or wanderlust. We saw last time that even this picture might require more refinement. The Apostle was a relational realist. It was not that this situation or that was the ideal. That is, it was not a one-size-fits-all Platonic form. On the other hand, this is not to deny that there is a norm. That norm is marriage. God still calls it good.
Now the Apostle throws us another curveball. In the same breath, and perhaps because of the special circumstances in Corinth, the “down sides” to marriage must be faced. It is not to scare us away from it, but to bring us into it with eyes wide open. Wise pastoral counseling in the premarital phase will frankly cover all of this terrain. What we typically do is turn away in repulsion, insisting that the only reason that one would be this “negative” is to dissuade from marriage. In fact, it brings greater conviction to marriage. It brings two people to marriage whose spiritual vitality apart from it makes them all the more ready to be in it. There are three reality checks.
Divided Interests
Disorderly Passions
Diverse Liberties
Note that our doctrine is the same as last time. That is because, though Paul is drilling deeper at these “reality checks,” he is never deviating from the ultimate value that holds over all circumstances: married or otherwise.
Doctrine. The value of marriage or singleness is relative to breaking our chains to this evil age.
Divided Interests
If you remember, this thought started back in verse 28: ‘Yet those who marry will have worldly troubles, and I would spare you that.’ Now Paul is ready to elaborate:
I want you to be free from anxieties. The unmarried man is anxious about the things of the Lord, how to please the Lord. But the married man is anxious about worldly things, how to please his wife, and his interests are divided. And the unmarried or betrothed woman is anxious about the things of the Lord, how to be holy in body and spirit. But the married woman is anxious about worldly things, how to please her husband (vv. 32-34).
One commentator says the uncomfortably obvious: “Christians who are single can give more time to the spiritual disciplines which give a person distinctive depth and impact in ministry.”2 This is counter-intuitive to many for a variety of reasons. In the first place, it seems to defy our common experience. In our day, the single are adrift. They have countless distractions of the basest sort. Within the church, at least in the last generation of pragmatic teaching, we have been taught that only marriage can give the prerequisite sanctification necessary for real kingdom service. The Bible actually says the exact opposite. Marriage is one thing that sanctifies us, but it is not the only thing; and when it comes to “man hours” in service in the body of Christ, it is single and empty nesters that obviously have the most time and energy for it. Married couples with children have the least. If we are going to talk about common sense, then ignoring this obvious fact will not help.
Note three things about the contrast in verses 32 to 34: (1) It is indeed a contrast between married and unmarried. So it makes a difference. (2) He calls the anxieties of the married life “worldly,” which reinforces the same word used back in verse 28. (3) He makes the spouse the object of the divided interests.
Now there are really three things you can do with this. At one extreme, you can ignore it or explain it away, which is the suburban American option. At the other extreme, you can inflate it and suppose Paul is really disparaging marriage, and so “Go and do likewise” with the Gnostics in the monastery. Let me suggest a third option, which takes into account all that Paul teaches on marriage and singleness. Let me suggest that our big idea remain the big idea, and that we take it seriously: Marry or not like there’s no tomorrow but forever. The meaning is this: If you marry, make sure it is to someone who believes this passage and will fight for your interests to not be so divided. When the question arises, “But dear, what kind of a Christian is he?” ensure that you can speak for the other that this is in fact their big idea. Understand that Paul’s common sense will still apply in a world of scarcity. Interests will be divided to some extent, but it need not be to a sinful extent. If not, if God is calling you to singleness short of having found that (and only that), then dig deep into the kingdom for a season, even if no partner travels with you.
Paul’s punchline tells us that he is not contradicting what he will say in Ephesians 5. He is giving these Corinthian believers an eternal perspective to apply wisdom to their divided interests: ‘I say this for your own benefit, not to lay any restraint upon you, but to promote good order and to secure your undivided devotion to the Lord’ (v. 35). But what do people often do with this instead? We disbelieve it and we dismiss it. We water it down, but typically we throw that water over our shoulders and run. We mumble these words quick and move on because of how crystal clear Paul is. No one actually can say with a straight face: “No Paul, the married man or women has just as much time and energy for ministry service and training and the mission field as an unmarried person.” And if you do think anything like that, your problem is not that you have this high view of marriage that you think you do. Your problem is that you are an American that grew up watching too many Disney movies and you probably think, “Well you can just ‘be whatever you want to be.’” And all Paul is saying here is, “No, you cannot!”
At a church in our not too distant past, only the young married couples with very small children were qualified to be in ministry. These few predictably got burned out. They then turned around and blamed that on “too much church” happening. Cue facepalm. Paul’s prescription is quite different.
For by the grace given to me I say to everyone among you not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think, but to think with sober judgment, each according to the measure of faith that God has assigned (Rom. 12:3).
Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall (1 Cor. 10:12).
The Corinthians had the problem of super-spiritualism; and it made many of them unrealistic about either the marriage relationship itself or about their lack of self-control. We arrive at the same place by other means, but ultimately it is a lack of relational realism and time management.
Disorderly Passions
‘If anyone thinks that he is not behaving properly toward his betrothed’—again, this word can be rendered “virgin,” but the ultimate meaning is “unmarried person” (male or female)—‘if his passions are strong, and it has to be, let him do as he wishes: let them marry—it is no sin’ (v. 36). This parallels what Paul had said about relations within marriage. Part of the function is to restrain a lack of self-control. We may think this is pessimism, but it is not. To repeat, it is practical realism. The Proverbs speak of Lady Folly as the temptress of all mankind:
Let not your heart turn aside to her ways; do not stray into her paths, for many a victim has she laid low, and all her slain are a mighty throng (Prov. 7:25-26).
Unlike the general principles of the Proverbs, yet very much with is wisdom in mind, Paul’s emphasis here is as a pastor answering specific counseling questions. “Pastor! Am I in sin if we get married sooner!” Answer: No, in your case, you had better get married a few months earlier! Assessing who makes up such a case also involves wisdom; but what exactly is Paul doing? He is recognizing particular types of people in particular types of situations and counseling them according to the universal standard: Marry or not like there’s no tomorrow but forever. That standard is for everyone. It is the application that will be diverse.3 So, for example, ‘But whoever is firmly established in his heart, being under no necessity but having his desire under control, and has determined this in his heart, to keep her as his betrothed, he will do well’ (v. 37). He triply qualifies himself and says, “The guy who is these three things—establishes a track record, shows self-control, determines in his heart to be with her—he does well to keep her in the engagement process but not yet marry.” Now, that is pretty specific counsel to make it into the Bible! On the other hand, with that exception, Paul is not giving an exhaustive list of applications here. Rather, in this one very specific counseling example, he is modeling how to apply the universal principle to specific circumstances. Wisdom must take the lesson and take it from there.
Here, perhaps, is the reader’s first test of that wisdom: i.e., Can you see the utter contrasting circumstances and remember that these are circumstances and not the universal principle? Let us read and test ourselves, as Paul brings out the most contrasting language: ‘So then he who marries his betrothed does well, and he who refrains from marriage will do even better (38). As a test within the test, recall that “do even better” has a kingdom context here. We must not water down that context. We may be quick to say, “Sure, but he is not saying that the unmarried servant of God is somehow ‘more spiritual.’” Indeed, that is true enough, if by “spiritual” one means “more virtuous” or “more righteous in God’s sight.” On the other hand, if one means to pretend that there is no difference in spiritual service, then I must inform you that you are still in denial.
One last point about this “even better.” We must draw the distinction already made even thicker. I do this to avoid any lingering misunderstanding. There is a calling of singleness. When we speak of a “call,” that often has formal connotations. However, we can speak of a general sense in which we mean the Lord’s lot for us. He has ordained our particular circumstances. Whatever else can be said, let us at least say that a gracious heart under the circumstance of singleness really is in a “better” state, not because of this or that circumstance but because of their contentment: “for I have learned, in whatever situation I am, to be content” (Phi. 4:11). It is a contentment both in God’s providence and God’s design. These two are distinct and both crucial here. We would not speak of this sort of single Christian as “delaying” marriage precisely because God is plainly the one withholding it. They prove this out by resisting any bitterness about what God has for them (providence) and what God has ordered more generally in marriage and the home (design). One sees a picture of a Christian family at Easter time, and there is yet another child. One must strain to count them all. And they all smile. So does the one who is content. Such a single Christian is most blessed and can be more of a blessing to others. Remember that when we get to specific application below.
Diverse Liberties
And now the most sensitive subject of the three, and therefore the most crucial in order to see just how complex the area of application is. Paul continues, ‘A wife is bound to her husband as long as he lives. But if her husband dies, she is free to be married to whom she wishes, only in the Lord’ (v. 39). If we apply the same standard to the question of divorce and remarriage as we just saw about getting married in the first place, we will be able to hear Paul. Like Jesus, he is not giving us an exhaustive list.
It was also said, ‘Whoever divorces his wife, let him give her a certificate of divorce.’ But I say to you that everyone who divorces his wife, except on the ground of sexual immorality, makes her commit adultery, and whoever marries a divorced woman commits adultery (Mat. 5:31-32).
Jesus was quoting Deuteronomy 24:1-4 there. It became known as “the any cause clause,”4 that abusive men would use to throw their wives to the curb. Jesus was saying, in effect, You cannot use that reason for divorce—That law was aimed at sexual immorality. And He adds, “Because of your hardness of heart Moses allowed you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it was not so” (19:8), and then He repeats the exception in the next verse.
I have been in debates with people who will insist that this makes the exception “no exception at all.” They point to the fact that Jesus points to their hardness of heart: that the divorce option was not God’s will. Indeed, we agree with that. Divorce, considered in the abstract, is never God’s will. Divorce, considered in the concrete, is to confirm to the ideal, and so is not “in God’s will” either. Yet here is a case where we can easily pursue over both universal principle and specific circumstance in a way that ignores other dimensions of God’s will. To cite an intertextual example, this this ignores that Deuteronomy 24 was indeed God’s law, and therefore cannot be excluded from this whole class we are calling “God’s will.” By “hardness of heart” the Lord meant to refer to anyone who is guilty of the divorce. I came to realize that the people I was arguing with really believed that since “It takes two to divorce,” any time it happens, both have obviously been hardened, at least in the ultimate act called “divorce.” They miss the whole context of real life.
The same Lord who hates divorce also hates abuse and oppression and other forms of harm. The context of Jesus’s correction was men who abused the words of God’s law. The law in Deuteronomy was a kind and gracious protection for women who were being victimized by the hardened hearts of men who could get away with that. Likewise in 1 Corinthians 7 there is a context to “Pastor Paul.” Neither Jesus nor Paul ever meant that sexual immorality or this abandonment of the unbelieving spouse are the only possible grounds for divorce. The same logic applies to serious abuse. Anything that violates or terminates the covenant of marriage to such an extent that justice is the only thing that can be done for the victim, because in many cases, there are real, objective victims.5 In fact, the notion that physically beating a spouse is not grounds for divorce because the Bible does not use such language as “physically beating,” is just one more form of biblicism.
‘Yet in my judgment she is happier if she remains as she is’ (v. 40a). Not because marriage was bad (or that remarriage would be sinful); but rather because, having experienced God’s design for marriage, her soul will more likely be fulfilled by greater adventure in the wider kingdom of God. That is why he says earlier, “I wish that all were as I myself am” (v. 7). More context comes from Calvin, as he reminds his reader that for many ages women especially were discouraged from ever remarrying, even in the case of the husband’s death, so that there was a double-standard.6 Again, with the Reformation, we see this principle, “Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom” (2 Cor. 3:17).
As we would expect with such a deep principle, there are even more hard teachings at the application levels. Now the difficulty concerns self-denial and eternal perspective. Paul says,
She who is truly a widow, left all alone, has set her hope on God and continues in supplications and prayers night and day, but she who is self-indulgent is dead even while she lives (1 Tim. 5:5-6).
Paul is not saying that anyone who must be remarried is therefore branded “self-indulgent,” but rather he is holding up the opposite extreme to the saintly widow. It is the same as we have seen about singleness, only now applied to those who are now single after the death of a spouse.
Then comes “vintage Paul” with this exclamation point at the end: ‘And I think that I too have the Spirit of God’ (v. 40b). This could be either a jab at the “pneumatics,” as such would eventually be called by a full-blown Gnosticism, or else a way of getting closure on his counsel as “mere opinion,” given what look like judgments less than the “red letters,” in 7:6, 10, 11, 25, just in case any in his day wanted to reduce his words in the liberal way that we examined last time. Perhaps it was both.
Practical Use of the Doctrine
Use 1. Correction. We are constantly told about the idols of family, marriage being the chief in this domestic pantheon. It would seem that many in “late-stage-New Calvinism” have decided to push back against the suburban-pragmatic recovery of the home by swinging the pendulum right back. But as we have seen, this is an exercise in the pendulum swinging between circumstances for lack of understanding the general principle. We might say that all pendulum swings arise from ignorance of universals. The man who cannot see the immaterial principle is like a ground-dweller, crawling from scrap to scrap, putting together the infinite puzzle from random finite points. Paul’s words in this chapter cannot be taken to support this latest swing against the “idols” of the home. One might as well fire back that there are idols of wandering, idols of non-commitment, idols of career, and all of this cries out for some reference point that makes idols truly idolatrous, and begs the question as to whether something God designed could be anything other than good in itself. The misuse of a thing is no argument against its use.
Use 2. Instruction. Let us practice the principle again in a very practical and pressing matter of our day. Is it not obviously sound advise to tell young people to get married? My answer is simple. In most cases, Yes. But how can we say this in light of 1 Corinthians 7? The answer is just as simple. If the “light” one received from this chapter is to not marry—end of discussion—then they have mistaken the shadow for the light: the circumstance for the principle. Let me explain in one more way. In ancient societies where family members could locate two to three generations back to people who still lived under the same roof, it makes sense for Paul to counsel single people not to become so easily uprooted in case of some calamities ahead. Nowadays, Paul would give the exact opposite counsel to most young people living in the West, and yet he would do so by the exact same principle. Now the great need is to find your people. Now the problem is that marriage is delayed. Now the family is transient. Therefore, to apply Paul’s language today, marriage is an even greater “rooting” agent than in most times and places.
Use 3. Admonition. Most people in fact lack self-control. Self-control is called a spiritual fruit by Paul in Galatians 5. In fact, he includes it among the main features of what Christ brings to us in his gospel presentation to Felix (Acts 24:25). We should not in fact expect it to be the norm for young people, especially in our culture like ours. Note then that when I admonish those who delay marriage, I am speaking to those in the deliberate act of delay—not to those who are settled on God Himself ordaining it for the season or even long term. This would not apply to them because in their rarer case, the delay is not a sinful act.
Consequently, young man, the longer you delay marriage, the more your passions will become disordered in the fallen way of Adam. You will become more passive. You will become more resentful of the masculine mandate. You will become more susceptible our culture’s stronger numbing agents, so that where in times past, alcohol and drugs were the means of finishing off a wayward soul, now, as the devil takes sharper aim at the root of the man, the tools of medicine and psychology reach their final perversion and join the cultural assault on masculinity. These demonic Dr. Mengeles persuade the uncommitted that they are not males at all, and ought not continue to pretend so.
Likewise, young woman, the longer you delay marriage, the more your passions will become disordered in the fallen way of Eve. You will become more rebellious and more shrill. You will become more resentful of that which is truly feminine and you will recoil like a vampire at the sight of a cross whenever anyone brings up the glories of the home, as if they are something of a gargoyle hunting you as a dog catcher pursues a stray. Inside the ache for domesticity will be weighing, but you will increasingly suppress that, such that the act of suppression will transform you into the very monster you project onto “patriarchy.” Your natural instinct to nurture will turn outward to actual monsters, transferring affection from your would-be children to easier objects of abstract empathy. You will see violent hordes as victims to be let in, and pleading prophets as noxious weeds to be cut out.
As the man and the woman fall increasingly out of place, all will die; and those peoples who did not turn from such a light will have enough of nature in them to replace these spoiled, resentful, distorted souls. We too have a calamity: a context for this counsel.
____________________________________________________________
1. Aristotle, Ethics, II.8.
2. Prior, 1 Corinthians, 136.
3. It has even been suggested that one of the divisions in Corinth was yet another proto-Gnostic sect, so that the pneumatics were pressuring young virgins to put off marriage as an institution only for the simple, sensual somatics. Fee seems to have a view like this — cf. The First Epistle to the Corinthians, 327.
4. cf. Matthew 19:3 for that exact language.
5. Romans 7:1-3 shows the “termination” side by way of analogy. It was taken for granted because Paul used the termination of the life of the husband as grounds for termination of the law of marriage, as the analogy to point to the termination of the whole law’s demands upon the old man in Adam.
6. Calvin, Commentaries, XX:269